"a very subtle and impressive meditation on contemporary Quebec's historical imagination ... it deserves to become the focus of a wide-ranging discussion on the future of Canadian history. [Létourneau is] one of the subtlest minds to explore the possibility of writing history under conditions of postmodernity." Ian Mackay, Histoire sociale - Social History

"Stunningly intelligent, provocative, perceptive, and at once scholarly and poetic, this is a major book that ranks among significant works dealing with Quebec identity. Completely original ... it is the work of an eminent intellectual whose profound, sensitive, and rigorous analysis will renew the debate on this topic. This book must be read, reflected on, discussed, even taken issue with, but it must not be ignored." Louis Cornellier, Le Devoir

"This book that must be read by anyone who wants to understand the historical roots or present condition of Canada and Quebec. It will be integral all future debates on these topics. The book is full of stimulating and well-phrased ideas." Jean-Jacques Simard, Revue d'histoire de l'Amérique française

"One of the most original and brilliant historical works to appear in a long while. Létourneau seeks to exorcise the habitual demons of Quebec history: the melancholic ruminations and assumptions of failure that are tied to Quebec's refusal to bury a past it has deemed unfulfilled. Just such a burial is the price that must be paid if we are to embrace the future." Spirale